by More Information...
This study examined the effectiveness of legislation to regulate dogs of "dangerous breeds." The authors compared dog bite data in Spain before and after the Spanish Dangerous Animals Act was implemented. The study found that "dangerous breeds" were not overrepresented in dog bite reports before or after the legislation went into effect and that the legislation had no bearing on the prevalence of dog bites.
"The effectiveness and suitability of legislation regarding the issue of dangerous dogs, especially those targeting so-called ‘‘dangerous breeds’’ (DB), have been the object of a lot of criticism.
However, the shortage of scientific studies in this field makes an objective assessment of the impact
of current legislation difficult. In the present study, dog bite-related incidents from Arago´n (Spain)
were analyzed for a 10-year periods (1995 to 2004). With the aim of assessing the impact of the Spanish Dangerous Animals Act on the epidemiology of dog bites, data from the non-legislated (1995 to
1999) and the legislated period (2000 to 2004) were compared in 2 different areas (low- and high-populated areas)."
"According to the results, the population density did exert a significant effect on the incidence of dog bites, whereas the legislation in force did not. Popular breeds such as the German
shepherd and crossbreed dogs accounted for the great majority of the incidents during the 2 periods
of study. Specifically, the German shepherd proved to be over-represented significantly among the
canine population. Dogs in the dangerous breeds list, on the other hand, were involved in a small proportion of the incidents both before and after the introduction of legislation. The present results suggest
that the implementation of the Spanish legislation exerted little impact on the epidemiology of dog
"Besides the scarce effectiveness, the results suggest that the criteria to regulate only so-called
DB were unsuitable and unjustified. It is hoped that this study will be helpful in the elaboration of
future regulation measures in this matter."
Spot Check Number:
Dog bites, Spain
File Attachments: You must be logged in to access attachments (see login and registration links above)